Otsego County might be famous for baseball, but let’s be real—the food scene is the true MVP. Now, we’re not saying this list covers everything amazing in the area, but these are some of the best of the best (and yes, it’s our opinion, but we think you’ll agree). Whether you’re into hometown classics, award-winning bites, or just want to eat your way through some truly unique spots, we’ve got you covered. Prepare for a delicious ride!

Hometown Heroes

Foods That Make You One of Us

First up, Tino’s Pizza in Oneonta. Sure, you’ve had pizza, but have you had the cold cheese slice? It’s a genius move where they toss a handful of cold, shredded cheese on top of a hot slice—why? Who cares? It’s fantastic, that’s why.

Then there’s Brooks’ House of BBQ, the holy grail of barbecue. This place has been serving up the most drool-worthy chicken for so long, they might as well make it the state bird. Pro tip: order the ribs and grab a bib—you’ll need it.

Big Deal Bites

Award-Winners and Foodie Fame

If you’re in the mood for something a little more fancy, Norbu should be on your radar. Chef Peter Beck, with his Michelin Star cred, is serving up Indian dishes that will knock your socks off (and then convince you to eat five more naan breads). You won’t just dine here; you’ll have a full-on culinary awakening.

Dining with a Side of "Whoa"

Unique Eats and Cool Vibes

Looking for more than just a meal? 1909 Brunch at The Otesaga Resort Hotel is where you need to be. It’s not just about eggs and bacon; it’s about sipping mimosas in a grand hotel overlooking the lake, making you feel like you’ve stepped into an F. Scott Fitzgerald novel.

Want something with a bit more quirk? Try Origins Cafe, where you’ll find yourself eating inside a greenhouse surrounded by lush greenery. The vibe is all "chic jungle," and the food is farm-to-table fresh. It’s a dining experience as unique as the Instagram shots you'll take.

And then there’s Dazzo’s in Oneonta, Dazzo’s in Oneonta isn’t just a restaurant—it’s a true culinary experience. Everything here is farm-to-table, from the fresh ingredients to the focaccia that will make you weep with joy. And the pizza? A wood-fired revelation. Circle-ish pies bubbling with perfection, crispy crusts, and that unmistakable smoky flavor that makes every bite a little piece of heaven. 

Global Bites

Around the World Without Leaving the County

Craving something international? Otsego County has you covered. Azul in Oneonta serves up Mexican food so good, you’ll think you’re south of the border. Their tacos are pure magic, and the margaritas are even better.

For a taste of Italy, head to Toscana Northern Italian Grill . You’ll feel like you’ve stepped into a cozy Tuscan trattoria, with pasta dishes that will transport you straight to Florence—minus the airfare.

Sweet Tooth Paradise

Where to Get Your Dessert Fix

When it’s time for dessert (or just a really good snack), Schneider’s Bakery is the place. Their donuts are legendary, and their pastries will make you question why you ever considered skipping carbs.

Ice cream fans, rejoice—Adeline Ice Cream and Cooper’s Barn are here to satisfy all your frozen treat cravings. And if you want something seasonal and oh-so-autumnal, swing by Fly Creek Cider Mill for fresh cider and baked goods that’ll make you wish fall lasted forever.

 

Festivals for Foodies  

Events to Plan Your Life Around

Don’t miss Belgium Comes to Cooperstown at Ommegang Brewery. This festival is all about Belgian beer, food, and more beer. It’s the ultimate event for anyone who believes that pretzels and a pint are the true soulmates of the food world.